China’s Belt and Road and COVID-19 Pose Security and Economic Challenges to Allied Countries
02 July 2020
Video of the meeting can be found at the bottom of the page
Convening for the first time ever on a digital platform, the NATO Parliamentary Assembly’s Economics and Security Committee held the first part of its annual Spring deliberations on 2 July 2020. The meeting, presided over by Committee Chairperson Ivans Klementjevs (Latvia), considered two draft reports, both by the Committee’s General Rapporteur, Christian Tybring-Gjedde (Norway): China’s Belt and Road Initiative: A Strategic and Economic Assessment and a draft Special Report on The Economic Consequences of the COVID-19 Pandemic.
Mr. Tybring-Gjedde first discussed the Committee’s draft General Report on the China’s Belt and Road initiative. He described the initiative as a “perfect expression of China’s global economic, diplomatic, and strategic ambitions”, adding that it would shape the geopolitical landscape of the 21st century in ways that the transatlantic community cannot ignore.
The BRI is actually three inter-linked initiatives: the Silk Road Economic Belt, the Maritime Silk Road, and the ‘Digital Silk Road’. Along these corridors, a broad array of infrastructure projects is underway including oil pipelines, roads, railways, ports, and digital networks, as well as a host of industrial investments. Beijing, Tybring-Gjedde noted, sees the Digital Silk Road as a means to establish a dominant position in a number of cutting-edge sectors. But it also seeks to use the BRI to align partner nations with its regulatory frameworks and overall international vision.
Mr. Tybring-Gjedde pointed to several specific risks the project poses to the West. These include allegations that the BRI funds and builds infrastructure that could be used to facilitate China’s military expansion while creating new opportunities for espionage, particularly through the Digital Silk Road. It also creates debt traps through opaque lending practices. The scant attention Beijing pays to environmental sustainability risks creating long-term environmental hazards.
Questionable labour practices and Beijing’s blind eye to corruption are also deeply concerning, Tybring-Gjedde noted. The project, he told the Committee, is weakening international efforts to improve good governance not only in developing countries, but also in the West.
The rapporteur explored several of the specific challenges to the transatlantic community. China, he said, is pursuing a divide and conquer strategy in Europe through the BRI. While Washington sees China primarily as a rising power aiming to challenge its preeminent global position, for many in Europe, China offers commercial opportunities while also posing competitive threats. He added that “Allied countries will accordingly need to agree on a common approach towards China so that it does not become a fault line within NATO”.
The COVID-19 pandemic has brought some of these tensions into greater relief. Mr Tybring-Gjedde pointed out that the US Administration has been very focused on China’s lack of transparency in the early stages of the pandemic. While many European governments share this concern, they express this concern in a different manner.
The rapporteur concluded by calling for the transatlantic community to hold out another model of development and investment based on principles of transparency, sustainability, and liberal market principals including free trade, and good governance. “We should all work to promote these values and to encourage China to embrace them as well”, he said.
The second half of the meeting was dedicated to Mr. Tybring-Gjedde’s special report The Economic Consequences of the COVID-19 Pandemic. He argued that pandemics act as negative exogenous economic shocks. These shocks can profoundly affect supply, demand, monetary and fiscal conditions. They can induce dramatic contractions in output, investment, spending, employment, and trade. The share of population infected, the number of work weeks lost, and the morbidity rate all determine the depth of the crisis.
Measures undertaken to minimise the impact of the pandemic can also undermine the economy, at least over the short term. “Lockdowns buy time”, Tybring-Gjedde told the Committee, by lowering pressure on health care facilities and workers and reducing rates of infection. But they can also shut down national economies. He warned that failing to generate social consensus around government measures to combat a pandemic will likely increase the duration of the medical crisis and even unleash political unrest.
Pandemics also have a very negative impact on trade, particularly once governments essentially shut down commercial activities and close borders. Meanwhile, the collapse of consumer spending exacerbates the recessionary effects of pandemics. The rapporteur told the Committee that falling consumer demand, lockdowns, collapsing trade and a Russian-Saudi oil price war have all struck a hard blow at energy markets which have been plagued by plummeting prices. The banking sector is also teetering on the edge, particularly given the substantial amount of debt that companies and governments held in the run-up to the crisis.
The speaker then explored government responses to this burgeoning crisis. He noted that central banks can counter this by keeping interest rates low and by offering collateralised lending to the financial system. But there are risks, he added. Government balance sheets have substantially worsened, and there is a mounting moral hazard in which firms come to assume that governments will always willingly bail them out. This risk, however, is now outweighed by the systemic threat posed by the potential spiral to depression, Tybring-Gjedde asserted.
Tybring-Gjedde’s presentation concluded with a strong plea for deeper international collaboration. No country can resolve either the medical or economic crisis on its own, he said. Deepening international collaboration is not an objective driven by some internationalist idealism, but rather by a clear understanding of how best to defend national interests in a globally integrated economic order. It will also be essential to preserve an open trading order, he added.
There are lessons to be learned in the midst of this crisis. Most obviously, failing to prepare for future pandemics could well prove catastrophic. The speaker called for a rethinking about “how we collectively define national security, because the damage that pandemics can potentially inflict are not so dissimilar to the impact of war or civil strife”.
He finally noted that NATO member governments and parliaments should rededicate themselves to preserving the 2% of GDP defence spending commitments to which all NATO governments have signed up.
The Economics and Security Committee will convene a second digital meeting in early September. At that gathering, Ausrine Armonaite (Lithuania) will present her draft report on The Black Sea Region: Economic and Geopolitical Tensions, and Jean-Marie Bockel (France) will discuss his draft report on The Gulf Crisis and Global Energy Markets. These reports, along with the two reports by Christian Tybring-Gjedde, will be revised over the summer for their second and final reading at the Annual Session of the NATO PA, which will be held in Athens, Greece.
Michal SZCZERBA (Poland) - PRELIMINARY DRAFT REPORT
Ukraine’s reconstruction will not simply be essential for Ukraine. It will, in fact, be critical to reinforcing Europe’s security architecture and its democratic way of life. Indeed, European peace, security and economic vitality ultimately…
2023 - REBUILDING TRANSATLANTIC ECONOMIC RELATIONS AND RESILIENCE
Faik OZTRAK (Türkiye) - PRELIMINARY DRAFT REPORT
Democratic societies today are on the cusp of retreating from what some analysts describe as an era of hyper-globalisation because of national security considerations but also because of its apparent consequences for communities marginalised by the logic of open…
2023 - RUSSIA’S WAR ON UKRAINE AND TRANSATLANTIC ENERGY SECURITY CHALLENGES
Harriett BALDWIN (United Kingdom) - PRELIMINARY DRAFT GENERAL REPORT
Russia’s aggression against Ukraine and its willingness to use energy as a geopolitical weapon has destroyed expectations that it can be a reliable energy supplier. A mass European exodus from Russian oil and gas markets is underway, and this has induced a…
2022 – REPORT - THE WESTERN BALKANS: RUSSIA’S WAR ON UKRAINE AND THE REGION’S ENDURING CHALLENGES
Michal SZCZERBA (Poland) - REPORT
The countries of the Western Balkans have made varied progress in economic and political transition. One of the region’s countries is now a member of the EU and four have acceded to NATO. But the region’s transition is incomplete and there are signs of backsliding…
2022 - REPORT - STRATEGIC AND ECONOMIC CHALLENGES POSED BY CORRUPTION
Harriett BALDWIN (United Kingdom) - GENERAL REPORT
Corruption undermines national institutions that are critical to administering states, endangering national stability and deepening international differences. It enables terrorist and criminal networks both by providing vehicles for these groups to finance their…
The emergence of new trading powers and particularly China has fomented new tensions in the international trading system. At the same time, Russia, a declining and high disruptive country, poses grave and more immediate challenges. These tensions are largely driven by…
2021 - REPORT - THE GLOBAL ECONOMIC CRISIS: IMPLICATIONS AND PROSPECTS
Faik ÖZTRAK (Turkey)
This report was adopted by the Economics and Security Committee at the Annual Session of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly in Lisbon.
The longer-term consequences of the COVID-19 pandemic…
2021 - REPORT - ALLIED DEFENCE SPENDING: ENDURING THREATS AND NEW CONSTRAINTS
Christian TYBRING-GJEDDE (Norway)
This report was adopted by the Economics and Security Committee at the Annual Session of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly in Lisbon.
The COVID-19 pandemic and the global recession it has…
2021 - REPORT - BELARUS: POLITICAL, ECONOMIC, AND DIPLOMATIC CHALLENGES
Michal SZCZERBA (Poland)
This report was adopted by the Economics and Security Committee at the Annual Session of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly in Lisbon.
Following highly problematic August 2020 Belarusian…
2020 - SPECIAL REPORT - THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC AND THE MENA REGION
Gilbert ROGER (France), acting Chairperson
COVID-19 first appeared in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) Region in January 2020 in the United Arab Emirates (UAE). Since then the number of reported cases in the region has increased substantially. With the exception of Iran, infection rates in the region…
2020 - REPORT - NATO’S ESSENTIAL ROLE IN THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC
Attila MESTERHAZY (Hungary)
The Alliance reacted swiftly and effectively to do its part to mitigate the impact of the spreading coronavirus early in 2020. It continues to contribute to the fight that will lead to its ultimate defeat. To date, NATO has coordinated well over 350 missions to…
2020 - REPORT - CHINA'S BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE: A STRATEGIC AND ECONOMIC ASSESSMENT
Christian TYBRING-GJEDDE (Norway)
In 2013, Chinese President Xi Jinping announced perhaps the most ambitious investment and infrastructure programme ever conceived. The ‘Belt and Road Initiative’ (BRI) has since become the boldest expression yet of China’s global economic, diplomatic, and strategic…
2020 - REPORT - THE IMPACT OF THE COVID-19 CRISIS ON THE CIVIL DIMENSION OF SECURITY
Joëlle GARRIAUD-MAYLAM (France)
The COVID-19 crisis has a significant short- and long-term impact on many aspects of the civilian dimension of security. This special report firstly examines the link between repressive policies and the aggravation of the health crisis. It shows that human rights…
2020 - SPECIAL REPORT - COVID-19, INTERNATIONAL SECURITY AND THE IMPORTANCE OF NATO STO
Kevan JONES (United Kingdom)
The SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus epidemic which was first identified in China in late 2019 has expanded to touch nearly every corner of the globe. The World Health Organization (WHO) assessed COVID-19 as a pandemic on 11 March 2020. The speed and the scale of the virus’ global spread have been…
2020 - REPORT - COVID-19 AND TRANSATLANTIC SECURITY
Lord CAMPBELL OF PITTENWEEM (United Kingdom)
“A global pandemic is not a question of if, but when and how bad”. Variations of this statement have over the years been repeated by countless health experts, yet when in late 2019 a novel coronavirus emerged in the Chinese city of Wuhan, much of the world found…
2020 - REPORT - THE BLACK SEA REGION: ECONOMIC AND GEO-POLITICAL TENSIONS
Ausrine ARMONAITE (Lithuania)
The Black Sea region is at once alive with economic potential and imperilled by division, rivalry and conflict ¬¬¬– all with implications for the international system as a whole. It is an area united by an important waterway that links the littoral countries and…
2020 - REPORT - GULF CRISIS AND GLOBAL ENERGY MARKETS
Faik OZTRAK (Turkey)
The Gulf, like other parts of the Middle East, is both a source of friction and cooperation between Europe and the United States. This reflects both convergent and divergent interests in the region, but it is also emblematic of more enduring changes underway in the…
2020 - REPORT - CHINA AND THE GLOBAL LIBERAL ORDER
Lord JOPLING (United Kingdom)
The contemporary global liberal order, established in the aftermath of World War II, and the values of individual liberty, democracy, human rights and rule of law that underpin it have formed the foundation of the Alliance since its creation. Using its expanding…
2020 - REPORT - THE ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCES OF THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC
Christian TYBRING-GJEDDE (Norway)
The global community is currently undergoing the most consequential pandemic since the outbreak of Spanish influenza in 1918-19. Pandemics, however, are not as rare as many have thought. Indeed, there have been four major pandemics over the last 120 years when flu…
2019 - MISSION REPORT PCNP ESCTD VISIT TO ADDIS ABABA, ETHIOPIA - 209 JOINT 19 E
Obtaining insights in Africa’s security dynamics related to the evolving security landscape in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region was the main focus of a NATO PA visit to Addis Ababa from 23 to 25 September 2019. The current state of cooperation between…
2019 - REPORT- NORTH AMERICAN AND EUROPEAN APPROACHES TO DIGITAL MARKETS AND CYBER SECURITY
Jean-Marie Bockel (France)
This ESCTER report was adopted on Saturday 12 October 2019 by the Economic and Security Committee at the 65th Annual Session of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly in London, United Kingdom.
…
2019 - REPORT - NORTH MACEDONIA - POLITICAL CHANGE, NATO ACCESSION AND ECONOMIC TRANSITION
Ausrine ARMONAITE (Lithuania)
This ESCTD report was adopted on Saturday 12 October 2019 by the Economic and Security Committee at the 65th Annual Session of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly in London, United Kingdom.
…
Azerbaijan has emerged as a key strategic partner for Europe. The much-anticipated completion of the Southern Gas Corridor in 2020 will mark a major step in diversifying the energy supply base of southern Europe. That project will bring significant quantities of gas from Azerbaijan’s massive…
2018 - THE FUTURE OF THE SPACE INDUSTRY - 173 ESC 18 E fin
Jean-Marie BOCKEL (France)
The report focuses on the rapidly shifting parameters of global space markets. These were once dominated by large countries with important military and scientific space programmes. Commercial market players today, however, are no longer supplying governments with…
2018 - THE INTERNATIONAL TRADING SYSTEM AT RISK AND THE NEED TO RETURN TO FIRST PRINCIPLES - 174 ESCTER 18 E fin
Faik OZTRAK (Turkey)
The unprecedented growth of the world economy over the last sixty years has been premised on liberal market reform and free trade. Worryingly, in recent years, there has been a backlash against free trade, and this has emerged as a common theme among populist political…
Iryna GERASHCHENKO, co-chairperson of the Ukraine-NATO Interparliamentary Council (UNIC) welcomed the delegates to Odesa and noted that the President of the Parliament had just presented a national security bill to the Rada. A number of allied countries helped with that…
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1. Japan will support the efforts by US President Donald Trump to negotiate a denuclearisation of North Korea but will continue to pursue a cautious approach toward the regime of the Democratic People’s Republic of…
2018 - MISSION REPORT ESCTER TOULOUSE PARIS FRANCE - 228 ESCTER 18 E
The space realm is evolving rapidly, and as it does, new commercial vistas are opening up that will transform the global economy. France has emerged as a leading player in space and is a driving force in Europe’s collective quest both to derive benefits from these…
2017 - ROSE-ROTH SEMINAR REPORT SLOVENIA - 013 SEM 18 E
96th ROSE-ROTH SEMINAR
SUB-COMMITTEE ON TRANSITION AND DEVELOPMENT (ESCTD)
SEMINAR REPORT THE WESTERN BALKANS:
PAST MISPERCEPTIONS, CURRENT CHALLENGES AND FUTURE ENDEAVOURS
LJUBLJANA,…
2017 - EUROPE INDUSTRIAL DEFENSE BASE - BOCKEL REPORT- 166 ESC 17 E bis
Report Title: The State of Europe’s Defence Industrial BaseRapporteur: Jean-Marie BOCKEL (France)Year: 2017
Whereas the members of the Alliance reaffirmed in Warsaw their commitment to devote 2% of their respective GDP on defence, while dedicating at…
2017 - ECONOMIC TRANSITION IN THE WESTERN BALKANS: AN ASSESSMENT
Richard BENYON (United Kingdom)
The Western Balkans remains an area of special concern for NATO, which first engaged militarily in the region during the early stages of the war in Bosnia and Herzegovina in 1992 and later during the Kosovo conflict. There has been a sustained effort to the support the…
2017 - CLIMATE CHANGE - ALFREDSDOTTIR REPORT -167 ESCTER 17 E bis
Report Title: Assessing and Mitigating the Cost of Climate Change Acting Rapporteur: Lilja ALFREDSDOTTIR (Iceland )Year:2017
This report explores a range of challenges linked to climate change and considers recent international efforts to cope with…