Russian Military Build-up and Crisis in Belarus at the Center of Polish Strategic Concerns
14 April 2021
Video of the meeting can be found at the bottom of the press release
From Poland’s perspective, Russia continues to pose the most serious threat for the Euro-Atlantic Alliance. Russia is bolstering its military capabilities right at the NATO doorstep while the exclave of Kaliningrad remains the most heavily militarised space in Europe.
Russia is relying on disruptive technologies, including new hypersonic missiles, capabilities to disrupt the sea lines of communication and A2/AD (anti-access and anti-denial) capabilities, Pawel Jablonski, Poland’s Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs, told members of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly (NATO PA) who participated in a series of online meetings with Polish officials and experts on 12-13 April.
Some 22 legislators from 12 NATO countries, members of the Assembly’s Sub-Committee on NATO Partnerships (PCNP) and Sub-Committee on Transition and Development (ESCTD) took part in the meetings. These meetings were co-chaired by PCNP Chair Prof. h. c. Dr. Karl A. Lamers (Germany) and ESCTD Chair John Spellar (United Kingdom) and hosted by Michal Szczerba, Deputy Head of the Polish delegation.
Mr. Jablonski said the transatlantic community ought to be very concerned about the Kaliningrad build-up and planned mass-scale Belarusian-Russian “Zapad-2021” manoeuvres which will bring an array of Russian forces close to the Eastern borders of NATO.
Jablonski also suggested that the build-up of Russian troops on Ukraine’s eastern border is deeply concerning. Elements of this brewing crisis are similar to what transpired just prior to the invasion in Crimea.
He called on NATO governments to apply significant pressure and more comprehensive sanctions on Russia to impose a cost on Russian actions and to demonstrate allied unity and shared purpose in the face of these provocations.
Other Polish politicians and experts also emphasised the urgency of the Russian military and political challenge. They applauded the Allied decisions to substantially bolster presence on the NATO’s eastern flank, including through the “Four Thirties” Readiness Initiative (having 30 combat ships, 30 land battalions, and 30 air squadrons ready to deploy within 30 days), but urged the Allied planners to work on scenarios for this 30-days period.
Polish interlocutors also urged Allied policy-makers, as part of the 2030 reflection process to act on a number of key recommendations, namely to strengthen the political dimension of NATO, to institutionalise the relations with the EU and to address the challenges to NATO as an Alliance based on shared democratic values.
Mr Jablonski warned that NATO governments need to enhance both societal and military resilience to better cope with hard military threats as well as hybrid and cyber disinformation challenges. “We need effective political deterrence that supplements the military one and makes it more credible both in the eyes of our adversaries and our own societies”, he said. “This instrument can be developed in close cooperation with our like-minded partners, especially the EU.”
Polish interlocutors stressed that Russia will continue its campaign to subvert western democracies, including through funding political parties and election interference. They suggested enhancing the exchange of best national practices in the protection of election infrastructure and ensuring transparency of political campaigns’ funding. They encouraged a more proactive role of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly in protection of election integrity within the Alliance and beyond.
The parliamentarians also focused closely on the situation in Belarus in discussions with Polish and Belarusian experts. The speakers noted that the peaceful political and social mobilization of the Belarusian people following the August 2020 presidential elections have had a transformative impact on Belarusian identity. In a sense, public outrage at the regime and the deep corruption that it has encouraged has forged a strong national identity which itself has now become a factor in the crisis.
One expert suggested that the social delegitimisation of Lukashenko has now reached the point of no return. There is no possible way for Lukashenko to gain the kind of authority that he would need to govern in a normal fashion. He has now resorted to the suspension of the rule of law and extraordinarily harsh repression. But in so doing, he is only digging a deeper hole for himself and his government. For their part, the Belarusian people are simply fixated on building a new and better Belarus that is democratic and committed to the rule of law. Panelists emphasised that the protest movement in Belarus is not geopolitical and should not be viewed as the choosing between Russia and the West.
Experts warned that Russia is exploiting the weakness of Lukashenko to press its case for deeper integration of the Russian-Belarusian union-state — a project that aims to subvert Belarusian sovereignty and national institutions. They told delegates that sanctions on Russia are needed to signal that this ambition is unacceptable. Simply talking with Putin would be doomed to fail. Stronger signals are needed but the international community must be unified and tough on this matter.
Michal Szczerba (Poland), who is also the ESCTD Rapporteur, has drafted a Sub-Committee report on the situation in Belarus which will be presented at the online Spring Session of the NATO PA in May.
NATO Parliamentarians also discussed Poland’s economic situation in the context of the pandemic. Maciej Witucki, Chairman of Lewiatan (Organisation of Employers), noted that the Polish economy proved to be quite resilient, and the government was open to consulting closely with the business community. Poland chose to take measured and pragmatic decisions on acute issues such as repatriation of elements of production chains back to Poland or regulating 5G networks. The Polish approach combines both the national security considerations and the interests of consumers, Mr Witucki said. He also stressed that the pandemic reinforced Poland’s resolve to transition towards a more digitalised and greener economy.
DAY 1 - Monday 12 April 2021
(Panel on Belarus was held under Chatham House rule)
DAY 2 - Tuesday 13 April 2021
(Panel on Russia was held under Chatham House rule)
2021 - REVISED DRAFT REPORT - THE TRANSATLANTIC LINK AND BURDEN SHARING IN THE CHANGING STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENT
Ahmet YILDIZ (Turkey)
This draft report discusses ways to rejuvenate the transatlantic bond and to seek fairer burden sharing in the context of the NATO 2030 agenda and the revision of NATO’s Strategic Concept. Despite the pandemic and other new challenges, NATO continues to demonstrate its…
2021 - REVISED DRAFT REPORT - NATO AND THE MEDITERRANEAN SECURITY AGENDA
Sonia KRIMI (France)
The Mediterranean Sea has three strategic entry points, providing access to the Atlantic Ocean, the Red Sea which leads to the Indian and Pacific Oceans, and the Black Sea which leads to Eastern Europe and Russia. Thus, the Mediterranean connects all the world’s major…
2020 - REPORT - CHINA'S BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE: A STRATEGIC AND ECONOMIC ASSESSMENT
Christian TYBRING-GJEDDE (Norway)
In 2013, Chinese President Xi Jinping announced perhaps the most ambitious investment and infrastructure programme ever conceived. The ‘Belt and Road Initiative’ (BRI) has since become the boldest expression yet of China’s global economic, diplomatic, and strategic…
2020 - GENERAL REPORT - THE RISE OF CHINA: IMPLICATIONS FOR GLOBAL AND EURO-ATLANTIC SECURITY
Gerald E. CONNOLLY (United States)
The rapid rise of the People’s Republic of China in the last part of the 20th century and early decades of the 21st century represents a paradigm shift in global affairs comparable in magnitude to the collapse of the Soviet Union.
2020 - REPORT - COVID-19 AND TRANSATLANTIC SECURITY
Lord CAMPBELL OF PITTENWEEM (United Kingdom)
“A global pandemic is not a question of if, but when and how bad”. Variations of this statement have over the years been repeated by countless health experts, yet when in late 2019 a novel coronavirus emerged in the Chinese city of Wuhan, much of the world found…
2020 - REPORT - THE BLACK SEA REGION: ECONOMIC AND GEO-POLITICAL TENSIONS
Ausrine ARMONAITE (Lithuania)
The Black Sea region is at once alive with economic potential and imperilled by division, rivalry and conflict ¬¬¬– all with implications for the international system as a whole. It is an area united by an important waterway that links the littoral countries and…
2020 - REPORT - GULF CRISIS AND GLOBAL ENERGY MARKETS
Faik OZTRAK (Turkey)
The Gulf, like other parts of the Middle East, is both a source of friction and cooperation between Europe and the United States. This reflects both convergent and divergent interests in the region, but it is also emblematic of more enduring changes underway in the…
2020 - REPORT - SECURITY AND POLITICAL DYNAMICS IN THE GULF
Ahmet YILDIZ (Turkey)
As the COVID-19 pandemic and ensuing recession are transforming the global security landscape, the Gulf region finds itself in a particularly vulnerable situation. The region’s volatile security environment was already of significant concern to the Allies and the…
2020 - REPORT - CHINA AND THE GLOBAL LIBERAL ORDER
Lord JOPLING (United Kingdom)
The contemporary global liberal order, established in the aftermath of World War II, and the values of individual liberty, democracy, human rights and rule of law that underpin it have formed the foundation of the Alliance since its creation. Using its expanding…
2020 - REPORT - THE NATO-EU PARTNERSHIP IN A CHANGING GLOBAL CONTEXT
Sonia KRIMI (France)
The relationship between NATO and the European Union (EU) – arguably the two most powerful multilateral bodies in modern history – is a recurring theme in international political debates, not only in Europe but also in NATO. Indeed, some members of the latter – not…
2020 - REPORT - THE ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCES OF THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC
Christian TYBRING-GJEDDE (Norway)
The global community is currently undergoing the most consequential pandemic since the outbreak of Spanish influenza in 1918-19. Pandemics, however, are not as rare as many have thought. Indeed, there have been four major pandemics over the last 120 years when flu…
2019 - MISSION REPORT PCNP ESCTD VISIT TO ADDIS ABABA, ETHIOPIA - 209 JOINT 19 E
Obtaining insights in Africa’s security dynamics related to the evolving security landscape in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region was the main focus of a NATO PA visit to Addis Ababa from 23 to 25 September 2019. The current state of cooperation between…
2019 - REPORT - SECURITY AND STABILITY IN AFRICA - CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR NATO
Julio Miranda CALHA (Portugal)
This PC General report was adopted on Saturday 12 October 2019 by the Political Committee at the 65th Annual Session of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly in London, United Kingdom.
Recent General Reports of the…
2019 - NATO@70: WHY THE ALLIANCE REMAINS INDISPENSABLE
Gerald E. CONNOLLY (United States)
This Sub-Committee report was adopted on Saturday 12 October 2019 by the Political Committee at the 65th Annual Session of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly in London, United Kingdom.
For the past 70 years, the…
Azerbaijan has emerged as a key strategic partner for Europe. The much-anticipated completion of the Southern Gas Corridor in 2020 will mark a major step in diversifying the energy supply base of southern Europe. That project will bring significant quantities of gas from Azerbaijan’s massive…
2018 - SECURITY IN THE WESTERN BALKANS - 178 PCNP 18 E rev1 fin
Raynell ANDREYCHUK (Canada)
The report provides a brief overview of the security environment in the Western Balkans. It argues that NATO and the European Union need to remain engaged to encourage the countries of the region to continue their reform process, providing assistance when necessary…
2018 - THE FUTURE OF THE SPACE INDUSTRY - 173 ESC 18 E fin
Jean-Marie BOCKEL (France)
The report focuses on the rapidly shifting parameters of global space markets. These were once dominated by large countries with important military and scientific space programmes. Commercial market players today, however, are no longer supplying governments with…
2018 - NORTH KOREA'S CHALLENGE TO INTERNATIONAL SECURITY - 179 PCTR 18 E fin
Gerald E. CONNOLLY (United States)
This report discusses the challenges posed by the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea (DPRK) - commonly known as North Korea- to regional and international security. It begins with a review of North Korea’s ballistic and nuclear weapons…
2018 - INSTABILITY IN THE SOUTH - 177 PC 18 E rev. 1 fin
Julio MIRANDA CALHA (Portugal)
This report reviews the main security challenges in NATO’s southern neighbourhood and their impact on NATO Allies. After providing a brief update on recent developments in Syria and Iraq, the report analyses the key drivers promoting instability in North Africa. To…
2018 - THE INTERNATIONAL TRADING SYSTEM AT RISK AND THE NEED TO RETURN TO FIRST PRINCIPLES - 174 ESCTER 18 E fin
Faik OZTRAK (Turkey)
The unprecedented growth of the world economy over the last sixty years has been premised on liberal market reform and free trade. Worryingly, in recent years, there has been a backlash against free trade, and this has emerged as a common theme among populist political…
Iryna GERASHCHENKO, co-chairperson of the Ukraine-NATO Interparliamentary Council (UNIC) welcomed the delegates to Odesa and noted that the President of the Parliament had just presented a national security bill to the Rada. A number of allied countries helped with that…
2018 - MISSION REPORT ESCTER TOULOUSE PARIS FRANCE - 228 ESCTER 18 E
The space realm is evolving rapidly, and as it does, new commercial vistas are opening up that will transform the global economy. France has emerged as a leading player in space and is a driving force in Europe’s collective quest both to derive benefits from these…
1. Japan will support the efforts by US President Donald Trump to negotiate a denuclearisation of North Korea but will continue to pursue a cautious approach toward the regime of the Democratic People’s Republic of…
2017 - CHALLENGES FROM THE SOUTH - MIRANDA CALHA REPORT -171 PCNP 17 E bis
Report Title: Tackling the Challenges from the South Rapporteur: Julio MIRANDA CALHA (Portugal)Year: 2017
Violent conflict and instability, particularly in Syria and Iraq, continue to destabilise the Middle East and North Africa (…
2017 - EUROPE INDUSTRIAL DEFENSE BASE - BOCKEL REPORT- 166 ESC 17 E bis
Report Title: The State of Europe’s Defence Industrial BaseRapporteur: Jean-Marie BOCKEL (France)Year: 2017
Whereas the members of the Alliance reaffirmed in Warsaw their commitment to devote 2% of their respective GDP on defence, while dedicating at…
2017 - RUSSIA - JUKNEVICIENE REPORT - 170 PC 17 E rev1 fin
Report Title: Russia – From Partner to CompetitorRapporteur: Rasa JUKNEVICIENE (Lithuania/Lituanie)Year: 2017
NATO-Russia relations are currently at their lowest since the end of the Cold War. Moscow’s provocative stance and actions towards NATO, and…
2017 - BURDEN SHARING REVISITED - KALNINS REPORT - 210 PC 17 E bis
Report Title: Burden sharing revisitedRapporteur: Ojars Eriks KALNINS (Latvia) Year: 2017
Since its founding, NATO has served as a transatlantic forum for political dialogue and consultation to define common political positions and adopt diplomatic…
2017 - NATO AND SECURITY IN THE ARCTIC - CONNOLLY REPORT -172 PCTR 17 E rev1 fin
Report Title: NATO and Security in the ArcticRapporteur: Gerald E. CONNOLLY (United States)Year: 2017
The Arctic region, or High North, ranked top of the security agenda during the Cold War due to its strategic importance. Its significance was largely…
2017 - ECONOMIC TRANSITION IN THE WESTERN BALKANS: AN ASSESSMENT
Richard BENYON (United Kingdom)
The Western Balkans remains an area of special concern for NATO, which first engaged militarily in the region during the early stages of the war in Bosnia and Herzegovina in 1992 and later during the Kosovo conflict. There has been a sustained effort to the support the…
2017 - CLIMATE CHANGE - ALFREDSDOTTIR REPORT -167 ESCTER 17 E bis
Report Title: Assessing and Mitigating the Cost of Climate Change Acting Rapporteur: Lilja ALFREDSDOTTIR (Iceland )Year:2017
This report explores a range of challenges linked to climate change and considers recent international efforts to cope with…
2017 - MISSION REPORT - CDS/PC VISIT TO THE UNITED KINGDOM
During the four-day visit to London and York, NATO Parliamentarians received briefings on, inter alia, the challenge posed by Daesh, instability in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region, counter-terrorism, as well as UK civil protection and emergency relief…